From the standpoint of those of us who have been sitting on the fence on the Anthropogenic Global Warming (AGW) theory, the leaked emails and research data and the reaction of the pro-warming crowd has gone a long way in pushing us to the opposition.
If the AGW theory were really valid, then surely there must be some real proof that (a) CO2 emissions have been rising as rapidly and consistently as the warmist camp says, (b) temperatures have been rising during that same period, and (c) that (a) caused (b). But no, there was just the strident calls to silence the opposition.
I used to enjoy listening to Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcasts (theskepticsguide.org) featuring a group of self described skeptics who skewered psychics, quack medical cures and spoon benders. But they grew tiresome when it became clear their politics had so much influence on their thought processes, and they would ruin something with an offhand remark like, "Bush ruined science." Huh? They were all so completely on board with the anti-Bush narrative that they felt such a remark needed no explanation.
They were so smitten with the AGW theory that they tagged the theory's skeptics with the name "global warming deniers," you know, like Holocaust deniers. For people who called themselves "skeptics" there sure seemed to be a lot of group-think conformity.
So I had to go back to them for their take on Climategate, and episode 227 on November 25, 2009, has an 11 minute discussion beginning at around 34:00.
Sure enough they circled the wagons, defended the global warming narrative, and tried to link global warming skeptics with tobacco industry efforts to confused the link between smoking and cancer. At worst, Climategate is just an embarrassment but shouldn't change anybody's mind, they say. And they bristled over the use of the word "skeptics," they are the the true skeptics, you see. Those who are skeptics of the global warming science on which the warmists rely are just "deniers."
To those of us in the cheap seats, the shrillness of the warmists was supposed to alarm us into acceptance, but it had the effect of hardening our resistance. And with Climategate developing, and the warmists in deer-in-headlight mode, it's time to enjoy the Schadenfreude.